
Diagnosis and detection
> In *Diagnosis and Detection*, Pasquale Accardo has determined to rescue Holmes and Watson from the historicism, psychologism, and armchair pseudo-analysis in which they have become entangled and to place them squarely in the company of the greatest creations of the Western literary imagination. In medicine and history, and in literature and myth, the author searches out and explores the archetypes that have contributed to the great detective's universal appeal. Sherlock Holmes is revealed to be an adversarial hero of the first magnitude, and a countercultural champion of intuition and insight, vision and discovery. >Although much Sherlockian scholarship has tried to elaborate the historic background and symbolic meaning of the Holmes canon, it has relegated the articulation of the mythic substructure of the works to random oblique comments or occasional footnotes. Sherlock Holmes is routinely presented as a symbol of the rational approach to problem solving. However, Accardo finds that symbol and myth are frequently at cross purposes, with the symbol representing a later attempt to rationalize away the primitive mythic content. >Earlier critical assessments of Sherlock Holmes's d
For young readers
Book data: Open Library