Skip to content

Damned if you, but not if you did

by Eugene M. Caruso

Judgments and decisions based on emotion often lead to systematic departures from rational models of behavior. Recent research has found that people's emotional reactions to future events are more extreme than their emotional reactions to equivalent past events (Caruso, Gilbert, & Wilson, 2007; Van Boven & Ashworth, in press). Because moral intuitions are guided by emotional reactions (Haidt, 2001), I suggest that moral judgments will typically be more extreme for events set in the future than for events set in the past. In Study 1, participants felt that they (but not another person) deserved more money for a future day of work than for a past one. In Study 2, participants stated that they (but not another person) would be more likely to reject an unfair split of money next week than last week. Participants in Study 3 rated a price-gouging vending machine as less fair if it was going to be tested next month than if it had already been tested last month. In Study 4, participants confronted with a moral dilemma thought that either of two decisions--both of which led to different negative outcomes--was less morally acceptable in the future than in the past. Both a past and a future v

Writing a summary for young readers…

For young readers

Book data: Open Library